HaruhiMiyazaki |
and "The Catcher In The Rye"
When I was an adolescent boy, I often told a lie. I used to tell my teacher lies
and tell my friends and my parent lies, too. Though I couldn't remember what
kinds of lies I had told, I told a lie frequently. Especially, when I was
a junior-high school student, I might told a lie every day deliberately.
After that, bitter taste remained in my mouth as a compensation for telling
a lie. I will not be able to forget this sensitive in my mouth how bitter I
told a lie then. Every time I told a person a lie to deceive, I felt I was
deceived. Therefore, I made up my mind I stopped telling a lie absolutely.
But, then, I had noticed that I had already told myself a lie.
I have read "The Catcher In The Rye" by J.D.Salinger in Japanese translation
before. I can't remember whether I was a high school student or junior-high
school student then. Yet this novel made a strong impression on me. I have
still remembered the main character, Holden's difficulties in his mind of
the age of puberty. As time goes by, I found by chance this book in English
when I dropped in at the book store in downtown 7 months ago.
What is the difference between adults and adolescent boys and girls
in general? According to a famous criminal psychologist, if they could tell
an adult a lie with ease and without any hesitation and deceive completely,
their mind must be as good as the adult's one.
Anyway, an adolescence which lies midway between adults and
children is a complete term. So, we can image that two ideas between
"I want to grow up a adult right now" and "I want to make up someone
once again" are separated with the sensitive and reason intricately.
We can also understand that the adolescent boys and girls often suffer
from this difficulties in this time. My opinion is that the key points
of this novel are difficulties and complications between Holden's mental
dependence and independence.
If you read this novel, it is not difficult for you to see that
the main character, Holden is an overprotected youth who was brought
up in a comfortable circumstance. What I thought something very carefully
in this novel is about his own real human nature.
For instance, speaking of his personality and character, Holden has
often used some words such as "phony " or "artificial" for Lillian Simmons
who was the former D.B'.s girlfriend, Ivy-students, Ossenberger who
donated a large sum of money to Holden's high school, Carl luce who was
a Holden's friend and the student at the Whooton, the actors which he
saw in the theater, and the audience who smoked outside the theater in
interruption. Holden was a perfect stranger to some of them or acquainted
with other a little bit. Viewed objectively, I couldn't find in this novel
that they had bad personalities as Holden called them "phony" or "artificial.
In addition, Holden bought a prostitute in the hotel which he stayed. As
he said to us in this novel, he was a virginity. But he behaved as a playboy
for her. He told her a lot of lies and talked irresponsibly, too. That reminds
me though he had talked to a primp before he got her, the conversation was
very unnatural awkward. This prostitute and primp would have seen it with
ease that he told them lies.
It was distressing scenes for me that the more he behaved showy, the more
he showed off how young he was. As you saw it, I can draw conclusions that the
great discrepancies between Holden's speeches and actions, or a one-sided
assumption is typical his personalities in his 16 years old.
A human being is unreliable and doubtful originally. To be honest, I have
still told a lie occasionally to protect myself and betrayed another to justify.
This is the evidence that I am not a real adult in my mind. Recently, I am
often sunk hopelessly in self-hatred for such my behaviors after I finished
reading this novel.
We could be agreed that a society is overflowed with many deceptions
and hypocrisies. Looking back upon my adolescent days, I used to look for
a innocent world as my ideal. Off course, I couldn't find my own utopia
then. The meanings of these words "phony" or "artificial which Holden has
often used in this novel repeatedly may be referred to the human being who
were up to their neck in this disgrace society. Therefore, when adolescent
boys and girls set foot into the world of adult, they had to prepare to
the mental development by themselves. The reasons why he was hospitalized
in the last scene of this novel are that he couldn't endure to set foot
into the world easily to be his immature mentality. The world was cruel
and harsh for Holden who had a pure and innocent mind.
In my conclusion, I guess that J.D.Salinger may have emphasized as one
of cautions not only mental frailty of adolescence but also the deception
and hypocrisy of modern society as seen through this novel.
August 1999 |